From the first time we are introduced to siblings, Dagny and James Taggart, it is immediately clear that the two characters represent completely different sides to the central struggle of the novel. The two characters are introduced separately, yet it is obvious that they do not share the same morals, standards, or values. Dagny represents capitalism, while James represents socialism, two extremely different theories of social and economic organization. Dagny is characterized as a confident, dauntless, and vigorous woman who is a visionary and appreciates fruitful, important work. She is a practical, hardworking woman not taking what is unearned and gives credit where credit is due, working for her realistic self-interest. James, on the other hand, is the opposite. Where Dagny is rational and objective, James is irrational and subjective, looking to the public opinion to make his decisions. James is weak and altruistic, focused on selflessness, and takes credit for others’ work. He does not care for anybody else, only considering himself, and has no regard for the sacrifice forced upon others.
When Dagny proposes the idea of using Rearden Metal, James is skeptical and criticizes her choice. Even though Dagny has done her research and established that Rearden Metals is high caliber and can yield a large profit, James is afraid of using Rearden Metal, solely based on the fact that nobody else has used it. Even though other companies have better, more substantial products than the company he wants to go with, James argues against Dagny based on his socialist views. After he begrudgingly consents Dagny to go ahead with using Rearden Metal, he makes it clear that it is her responsibility and if anything goes wrong, the blame is on her. This perfectly demonstrates how the weak (James) avoid blame and fail to take actions for anything they might be held accountable for in the future and how the strong (Dagny) rely on their instincts and accept responsibility regardless of the consequences.
No comments:
Post a Comment